ISSUE: 1/2020

  • Volume 24
  • Number 1
  • 2020


Studia Europejskie –
Studies in European Affairs

ISSN: 1428-149X
e-ISSN: 2719-3780

Ccbync License


Articles published in the journal are under a Creative Commons Attribution – Non Commercial – No Derivatives 4.0 International License

Funkcje integracji europejskiej z perspektywy subpaństwowych elit politycznych. U źródeł proeuropejskiego konsensusu w Szkocji

Functions of European Integration from the Perspective of Sub-State Political Elites. At the Root of the Pro-European Consensus in Scotland


This article aims to explain the phenomena of incredibly broad consensus among the Scottish political elites around European integration. All relevant political forces (present in the 2016–2021 term in the Scottish Parliament) have unequivocally supported further membership. European integration and the EU are specifically defined in public debate to carry out certain functions from the perspective of the Scottish political elite. These interpretations in this text are divided into three categories, serving three basic functions: facilitation of the process of increasing the competences of Scottish institutions (through independence or decentralisation), support for social development based on left-wing values and strengthening the distinctiveness of Scotland’s national identity. They were distinguished through in-depth analysis of scientific literature, documents of public institutions and political parties and statements of Scottish politicians. Author concludes that the distinction between the three basic functions of European integration from the perspective of the Scottish political elite is justified, although it is not always possible to draw a precise line between them. It is also easy to see that there are interrelationships between the different elements of these functions.


Arter D., The Scottish parliament: a Scandinavian-style assembly?, London 2004, DOI:

Arter D., Democracy in Scandinavia: consensual, majoritarian or mixed?, Manchester 2006.

Bailes A.J., Þórhallsson B., Johnstone R.L., Scotland as an Independent Small State: Where would it seek shelter?, “Stjórnmál og Stjórnsýsla” t. 8, nr 1/2013, DOI:

Barker F., Civic and Economic Nationalism: The Scottish Turn to Immigration, w: Nationalism, Identity and the Governance of Diversity. Old Politics, New Arrivals, ed. F. Barker, New York 2015, DOI: https://doi. org/10.1057/9781137339317_5.

Beauregard D., The Cultural Conceits of Subnational Governments of National Minorities: A Comparative Analysis of the Cultural Policies of Québec, Scotland, & Catalonia, Ottawa 2016.

Birrell D., Gray A.M., Devolution: The Social, Political and Policy Implications of Brexit for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, “Journal of Social Policy” t. 46, nr 4 (specjalny)/2017, DOI: S0047279417000393.

Bonino S., Muslims in Scotland: the making of community in a post-9/11 world, Edinburgh 2016. COSLA Guide to the EU Referendum. Scottish Local Government influencing the EU agenda, (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Czapiewski T., Szkocja wobec Unii Europejskiej w kontekście referendum niepodległościowego, w: Kryzys liberalnej demokracji w Europie i próby jego zażegnania, red. S. Ossowski, Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek, Toruń 2015.

Czapiewski T., Polska migracja do Szkocji po akcesji do Unii Europejskiej, „Przeszłość Demograficzna Polski” t. 38, nr 3/2016, s. 151–175, DOI:

Czapiewski T., Referendum niepodległościowe w Szkocji jako klęska i triumf Szkockiej Partii Narodowej, „Przegląd Zachodni” nr 1, t. 358/2016, .

Czapiewski T., The Political Myth of Margaret Thatcher in Scotland, „Polish Political Science Yearbook” t. 45/2016, DOI: https://doi. org/10.15804/ppsy2016007.

Czapiewski T., Między niepodległością a Unią Europejską. O paradoksach postawy Szkockiej Partii Narodowej wobec Brexitu, „Politeja” t. 46, nr 1/2017, DOI: Politeja.14.2017.46.04.

Czapiewski T., Referendum niepodległościowe w zmieniającym się systemie politycznym. Przykład Szkocji i Zjednoczonego Królestwa, w: Zmiany w systemach politycznych w Europie i na Świecie, red. K. Kamińska-Korolczuk, M. Mielewczyk, R. Ożarowski, Wydawnictwo Athenae Gedanenses, Gdańsk 2017.

Dardanelli P., Between Two Unions: Europeanisation and Scottish Devolution, Manchester 2006, DOI: 719070808.001.0001.

Devine T.M., In Bed with the Elephant, “Scottish Affairs” nr 57/2006, DOI:

Doughty H., Spöring M., Modern Languages in Scotland in the Context of Brexit, w: Languages after Brexit. How the UK Speaks to the World, red. M. Kelly, Palgrave Macmillan 2018, DOI: 3-319-65169-9_12.

Election 2015: Sturgeon says only ‘material change’ could spark Scots referendum, 8.04.2015, 22806 (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Engström R., The (dis) continuation of Scottish nationalism? A discursive comparison of the Scottish National Party and National Collective, “Journal of Political Ideologies” t. 23, nr 1/2018, DOI: 69317.2017.1397915.

Evans L., Does the tantrum-prone SNP not realise how privileged Scotland is?, “The Spectator” 13.06.2018.

Georghiou N., Evans A., Brexit: the impact on equalities and human rights, “Scottish Parliament Information Centre Briefing” nr 82/2016.

Gilgrist J., Imagining the Scottish Economy: Economic (In)Security and the ‘Hidden Politics’ of Independence, Plymouth 2017.

Haesly R., Identifying Scotland and Wales: types of Scottish and Welsh national identities, “Nations and nationalism” t. 11, nr 2/2005, DOI: https://

Harris S., Muslims in Scotland: integrationism, state racism and the ‘Scottish dream’, “Race & Class” t. 60, nr 2/2018, DOI: 0306396818793583.

Henceroth N., Jensen C.B., Confrontation and competition: The electoral benefits of regionalist parties’ positions in parliamentary democracies, “Party Politics” t. 24, nr 6/2018, DOI: 1354068816688361.

Hepburn E., Scottish autonomy and European integration: the response of Scotland’s political parties, w: European Integration and the Nationalities Question, red. J. McGarry, M. Keating, London 2006.

Hepburn E., The New Politics of Autonomy. Territorial Strategies and the uses of European Integration by Political Parties in Scotland, Bavaria and Sardinia 1979–2005, European University Institute, Florence 2007.

Hepburn E., The Rise and Fall of a “Europe of the Regions”, “Regional & Federal Studies” t. 18, nr 5/2008, DOI: 13597560802351572.

Hepburn E., McLoughlin P.J., Celtic nationalism and supranationalism: comparing Scottish and Northern Ireland responses to Europe, “The British Journal of Politics & International Relations” t. 13, nr 3/2011, DOI:

Ichijo A., Entrenchment of unionist nationalism: devolution and the discourse of national identity in Scotland, “National Identities” t. 14, nr 1/2012, DOI:

Ichijo A., Scottish Nationalism and the Idea of Europe: Concepts of Europe and the Nation, London 2004, DOI:

Jackson B., The Political Thought of Scottish Nationalism, “The Political Quarterly” t. 85, nr 1/2014, DOI: 923X.2014.12058.x.

Jaskułowski K., Nacjonalizm bez narodów. Nacjonalizm w koncepcjach anglosaskich nauk społecznych, Wrocław 2009.

Jaskułowski K., Nacjonalizm obywatelski i etniczny: geneza i krytyka typologii, w: Nacjonalizm, etniczność i wielokulturowość na Bliskim i Dalekim Wschodzie, red. A. Jelonek, Kraków 2011.

Jeffery C., Hough D., Devolution and Electoral Politics: Where does the UK fi t in?, w: Devolution and Electoral Politics, red. D. Hough, C. Jeffery, Manchester 2006.

Jones L., Scotland’s Nordic unionists: From union to union?, Huddersfield 2016.

Mackie A., The Impact of National Identity on the Brexit Vote: Explaining the Variance in Support of the European Union Between Scotland and England, Helsinki 2018.

Mann R., Fenton S., Nation, Class and Resentment The Politics of National Identity in England, Scotland and Wales, London 2017, DOI: https://doi. org/10.1057/978-1-137-46674-7.

McAnulla S., Crines A., The rhetoric of Alex Salmond and the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, “British Politics” t. 12, nr 4/2017, DOI:

McGarvey N, Stewart F., European, not British? Scottish Nationalism and the EU Referendum, w: The Future of the UK. Between Internal and External Divisions, red. M. Guderjan, Berlin 2016.

Meyer S., The European Union: An Un-Democratic Leviathan That Britain Might Just Escape, “The Stream” 16.06.2016, (dostęp 5.02.2019).

Nagel K.-J., Transcending the National / Asserting the National: How Stateless Nations like Scotland, Wales and Catalonia React to European Integration, “Australian Journal of Politics & History” t. 50, nr 1/2004, DOI:

Nicola Sturgeon would change SNP name, 18.08.2017, com/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-40975105.

Pattie C., Johnston R., Scottish national identity: why the question of Europe could actually keep the UK together, 20.03.2017, politicsandpolicy/could-europe-prevent-the-break-up-of-britain/ (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Phipps A., Language Plenty. Refugees and the Post-Brexit World: New Practices from Scotland, w: Languages after Brexit. How the UK Speaks to the World, red. M. Kelly, Palgrave Macmillan 2018, DOI: https://doi. org/10.1007/978-3-319-65169-9_9.

Ramsay A., Nine reasons Scotland is more Remain, (and what will happen if it’s dragged out), 14.06.2016, (dostęp 5.02.2019).

Ramsøy Jerve E., Explaining Scottish and Catalan Secessionist Mobilization in the Framework of the EU, 2015.

Saltire Society, Report Of The Saltire Commission, http://www.saltiresociety. (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Scottish Government, Scotland’s Place in Europe, Edinburg 2016, https:// (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Sutherland C., Another nation-building bloc? Integrating nationalist ideology into the EU and ASEAN, “Asia Europe Journal” t. 3, nr 2/2005, s. 141–157, DOI:

Sutherland C., Nation building through discourse theory, “Nations and Nationalism” t. 11, nr 2/2005, DOI: 5078.2005.00199.x.

The Migration Observatory, Report: Immigration and Independence: Public Opinion on Immigration in Scotland in the Context of the Referendum Debate,

Report-Immigration_Independence.pdf (dostęp 15.02.2019).

Uberoi E., European Union Referendum 2016, “House of Commons Library Briefi ng Papers” 2016, No. CBP 7639, 29 June.

Walker G., The Labour Party in Scotland. Religion, the Union, and the Irish Dimension, Palgrave Macmillan, London 2016.

Webb K., The growth of nationalism in Scotland, Glasgow 1977.

Language: Polish

Pages: 45-66

How to Cite:


Czapiewski, T. (2020) "Funkcje integracji europejskiej z perspektywy subpaństwowych elit politycznych. U źródeł proeuropejskiego konsensusu w Szkocji". Studia Europejskie – Studies in European Affairs, 1/2020, pp. 45-66. DOI: 10.33067/SE.1.2020.3